blog

Archive for the ‘Tax Benefits and Incentives’ Category

Green Tax Benefits & Incentives Part #4

Thursday, February 4th, 2010

Does solar voltaic systems make sense in Minnesota? Let’s take a look at combining the current federal tax credits, pending Minnesota state rebate program and net metering benefit to see if it all can make sense.
Example:
4KWp Solar Photovoltaic System approximate cost = $36,000 40,000
- MN State Rebate = -10,000 -10,000
- Federal Tax Incentive = – 7,800 – 9,000
Total Net Upfront Cost = $18,200 – 21,000

Cost to finance @6%, 30yr loan = $109.12 – 125.91 per month
Less: Net Metering (assumption) = – 58.33 – 58.33 per month (assumes 5 sun hours per day, 7,00 KWh per year at .10per KWh)
Monthly Out of Pocket = – 50.79 – 67.58 per month

The above is based on reasonable assumptions. However, each installation is different based on solar equipment & installation cost, equipment performance, sun hours per day, electricity cost, mortgage interest rate, etc.

Another way to look at it is what happens if you pay the net upfront cost with cash out of pocket. Assuming a $21,000 net out of pocket cost the cash on cash return is 3.3% on a tax free basis. Not the highest yield, but better than leaving your money in the bank.

Other Considerations:
- Other incentives may apply depending on location, rural area, utility provider, etc
- Utility companies charge much higher rates in the summer months and the net metering assumptions shown here may be conservative.
- Assuming you stay in your home for an average of seven years (the American average) the cost to you for owning the system is approximately $5,000.00 (e.g. 60 per mo). The loan balance on $21,000 after 84 months is $18,824. If there is a twenty year life, the remaining value after seven years works out to $26,000.00. The question is will the home sell for more than the $24,824 ($18,824 + $5,000) you have invested in the solar system at that point? Not very likely since the out of pocket cost new was only $21,000.
- Your home WILL produce significantly less carbon. While there is no financial incentive to monitor carbon emissions at this time, the cap and trade bill in congress is trying to do just that. A carbon tax would most likely change these calculations considerably.
- You are less likely to have power loss in hot summer days.

So there you have it; as far as I can calculate, installing solar photovoltaic panels in Minnesota is not a net zero cost. For comparison purposes, the $21,000 cost in this example is on par with what it would cost to moderately finish an average basement.

Would you install solar photovoltaic panels given these economics?

Green Tax Benefits & Incentives Part #3

Wednesday, February 3rd, 2010

Frequently Asked Questions:

Question #1 – If I don’t have to file income taxes, can I still get the energy efficiency tax credit?
Answer – According to the IRS the tax credit is technically “non-refundable” which means at the end of the year you cannot get back more from the Federal Government than you paid in.

Question #2 – Is there an upper limit on tax credits?
Answer – There is no upper or lower limit on income for the energy efficient tax credits

Question #3 – Are the energy efficient tax credits limited by the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)?
Answer – For 2009 the energy efficient tax credits are NOT limited by the AMT. “Section 25 D” products (which include geothermal, solar, and wind, at 30% with no upper limit) are NOT limited by the AMT at all. “Section 25C” products (which include insulation, windows, doors, roofs, HVAC, and non-solar water heaters, at 30% up to $1,500) are NOT limited by the AMT in 2009, but are currently limited by the AMT in 2010, unless Congress amends the law.

Question #4 – Can the energy efficiency tax credit be carried over to future years?
Answer – The tax credit for products at 30% up to $1,500 CAN NOT be carried over to future years. You can’t even carry forward tax credit dollars from 2009 to 2010. But you can take part of the $1,500 in 2009, and the rest in 2010 – if they are for separate purchases (ex: you spend $3,000 on windows in 2009 and get a $900 tax credit on your 2009 taxes, then spend $2000 on an air conditioner in 2010 and get a $600 tax credit on your 2010 taxes).

The tax credit for the following products at 30% with no upper limit CAN be carried forward to future years:
• Geothermal Heat Pumps
• Solar Panels
• Solar Water Heater
• Small Wind Energy Systems
• Fuel Cells

You can carry forward the credit as long as the credit is still in effect. In this case, the credit is in effect through 2016. The energy efficiency tax credit is technically “non-refundable” which means at the end of the year, you can’t get back more in credits than you paid to the government in taxes throughout the year. If you are unable to claim the entire 30% of your purchase for the above products, you can carry forward the unclaimed portion to future years through 2016.

The tax credit for insulation, windows, doors, roofs, HVAC, biomass stoves, and non-solar water heaters CAN NOT be carried over. These credits are for 30% of the cost, up to $1,500 in 2009 and 2010

Question #5 – What is the maximum tax credit I can get for the energy efficient home improvements?
Answer – Many of the energy efficiency tax credits are limited to $1,500 combined total for 2009 and 2010. The $1,500 maximum tax credit covers insulation, windows & doors, roofs, HVAC, biomass stoves, and non-solar water heaters.

Improvements not affected by the $1,500 cap (and in effect through 2016) include:
- Geothermal heat pumps
- Solar water heater
- solar energy systems
- small wind energy systems
- fuel cells (up to $500 per .5 kW of power capacity)
You can get both the 30% tax credit (up to $1,500) and the 30% tax credit (with no upper limit). For example, you could replace your windows and get $1,500, and purchase a new geothermal heat pump and get an additional 30% tax credit (with no upper limit). However, these are non-refundable tax credits, so you can’t get more back in tax credits than you pay in federal income tax. The tax credits that are not limited to the $1,500 cap can be carried forward to future years.

Even if you received the full $500 for the tax credits back in 2006 or 2007, you are still eligible for the full $1,500 in 2009 and 2010

Question #6 – What parts of a geothermal heat pump are covered by the tax credit?
Answer – The majority of the geothermal heat pump property and it’s installation is covered by the 30% tax credit. All geothermal heat pump components certified by the manufacturer in the “Manufacturer Certification Statement” will be covered. There may be some add on components that will not be covered such as an emergency back-up system and the ducts. These components are not directly related to the efficiency of the covered geothermal heat pump property

Question #7 – How can I determine if I can collect the tax credit? Does it matter if I am getting a tax refund?
Answer – Whether or not you are getting a refund does not matter. What matters is your “tax liability” – which is the total amount of federal income tax you are responsible for paying.

These energy efficiency tax credits are technically “non-refundable” which means you can’t get more money back in tax credits than you pay in federal income taxes (your tax liability). Check your last year’s tax return to get a sense of your tax liability (line 61 on the 2008 1040 form, called “total tax”). You can claim all of your tax credits as long as your tax liability, is greater than zero after all tax credits have been applied.

For example, say your Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) is $50,000, your tax liability is $10,000 (before you apply tax credits), and you’ve had $12,000 withheld from your paychecks. In this scenario you could claim up to $10,000 in tax credits. If you are eligible for the entire $1,500 tax credit, then your tax liability ($10,000) would be reduced to $8,500. Since you already had $12,000 withheld, you will get a tax refund of $3,500 ($12,000 – 8,5000 = $3,500).

If your AGI was $50,000, your tax liability $10,000 (before tax credits were applied), and you had $8,000 withheld from your pay checks, you would still have the ability to claim up to $10,000 in tax credits. If you are eligible for the entire $1,500 tax credit, your tax liability ($10,000) would be reduced to $8,500 and you would owe the government $500 at the end of the year ($8,000 already paid in taxes – $8,500 tax liability = $500 final payment).

Green Tax Benefits & Incentives Part #2

Tuesday, February 2nd, 2010

Below is an overview of some the programs available and web sites to do additional research.

Federal Tax Credit: 30% of cost up to $1,500
Expires: December 31, 2010
Details: Must be an existing home and your principal residence. New construction and rentals do not qualify.
Covers: Biomass Stoves, HVAC (Advanced Main Air Circulating Fan), Insulation, Roofs, non-solar water heaters, windows and doors.

Federal Tax Credit: 30% of cost up with no upper limit
Expires: December 31, 2016
Details: Must be an existing or new home and your principal residence. Rentals do not qualify.
Covers: Geothermal Heat Pumps, Small Residential Wind, Solar Water and Photovoltaic Systems

MN State Sales Tax Incentive: 30% of cost up with no upper limit
Expires: No Expiration
Details: 100% sales tax exemption
Covers: Solar Water Heat, Solar Space Heat, Solar Photovoltaic, Small Wind

MN State Rebate Program:
Expires: When funds are exhausted
Details: $1.75 watt DC (up to $8,750) or $2.00 watt DC ($10,000) if installed by a NABCEP certified installer
Covers: Solar Photovoltaic up to 5KW

MN State Rebate Program:
Expires: When funds are exhausted
Details: $30.00 per square foot net aperture to a maximum of the lesser of 25% or $2,500 for new systems
Covers: Solar Water Heat

Xcel Energy Utility Rebate Program
Expires: Not Listed
Covers:
Central A/C: $180-$330, depending on efficiency
Air-source Heat Pumps: $180-$330, depending on efficiency
Geothermal Heat Pumps: $150/ton
Furnaces: $75-$100, depending on efficiency
Boilers: $100
Water Heaters: $40-$60 (standard); $100 (tankless)http://www.xcelenergy.com/SiteCollectionDocuments/docs/Home-Performance-Rebate-SignUp.pdf
Note: Utility rebates vary by utility provider

MN Net Metering
Expires: N/A
Details: Net metering allows a small electricity generator (e.g. residential home) to interconnect to the transmission grid and sell unused electricity back to the utility at the end of the month. Wind energy systems less the 40kw in size are eligible for net metering (Rule 7835 and Statute 216B.164)
Covers: Photovoltaics, Landfill Gas, Wind, Biomass, Hydroelectric, Municipal Solid Waste, CHP/Cogeneration, Anaerobic Digestion, Small Hydroelectric, Other Distributed Generation Technologies

Web Sites to check for more information:
http://www.dsireusa.org/
http://energytaxincentives.org/
http://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?c=tax_credits.tx_index

Green Tax Benefts & Incentives Part #1

Monday, February 1st, 2010

Would you buy a better performing car that will cost you less to own if the government paid you the difference between the car you can afford and the better performing one? Most people would not have to think very long or hard about that answer. The answer is a resounding yes! The question is, does it really work out that way when it comes to homeowner tax credits and incentives?

When it comes to green building there are a number of federal, state and local tax credits and other incentives that may affect building decisions. It is important to understand these tax benefits and incentives early on in the building process so you can properly determine which materials and equipment you may want to install.

Because tax credits and incentives are always a moving target, many builders are not very well schooled on what is available and how it can impact their prospective buyers. The unfortunate thing is the customer is getting cheated out of having the opportunity to decide one way or the other.

For example, there is currently a 30% tax credit through December 31, 2016 for Geothermal Heat Pumps. There is no upper limit on the tax credit. Let’s see how that might apply to the decision you make for the HVAC system in your new home. In an average 2,000-2,800 square foot two story home, a builder can install a HVAC system for approximately $10,000- $17,000. You can certainly spend much more, but you would be overspending. You can pretty much buy the best forced air HVAC system for about $17,000 or even a dollar or two less. This would include a 95% AFUE furnace with full modulating fan, 15 SEER Heat Pump A/C, zone controls, fully programmable thermostats, steam humidifier, etc.. The system would be fully ducted (meaning the return air vents would not just use wall cavities) and all ducts would be completely sealed. In our homes, this is our minimum “builder” standard. However, some builders might put in the cheapest system building code will allow and the cost can be trimmed down to as little as $10,000-$11,000 dollars. If you were to install a Geothermal system, the cost might be 25,000 to 28,000. However, the tax credit is 30% so the final net cost to you after tax credit would be $15,000 to $19,600. If you knew this information, would it affect your decision? My guess is you would at least want to know what the options are so you could fully consider them.

Over the next few days, let’s take a closer look at the tax federal and state tax credits and incentives that are currently available. The review is not meant to be exhaustive, so you may need to do additional research in your area. For sure, if your builder cannot answer questions about tax credits and incentives, keep looking.